| Posted at 01:46 PM on January 24, 2009 |
Everyone on YT has had their fair share of fuck-overage I'm sure. Just
recently I experienced some of the worst of it myself; Before I only
had to change audio on two lesser videos, changing the music was no big
deal. But last night I found out three of my more personal favorites
had been taken down: Silent Hill Particle Man, Richards Story (Snakes
are a Pain), and Welcome to Africa. I've already changed the audio, and
proceeded to upload them on a different video website (I'll link it at
the end of the post). I might of been too hasty, now that some
information has come to my attention, but I hope the information I'll
share will be a help to everyone for future references.
*OPTION 1 - DISPUTE!*
The most intriguing information so far I got from the help of pigfish99 (YT). He sent me this link: [link]
If
you follow that link, YT user DarkxiderX basically explains that all he
simply had to do was dispute the claim made against his removed video.
He says that his video was purely fan made, non profit, and properly
credited. With that said, his claim was lifted the next day. Now, I
don't know if it's only with certain songs/companies/artists where it's
that lenient, but I think that video is enough to encourage people to
at least try to dispute a claim. The worst that can happen is getting
ignored. I'm not 100% sure HOW to do this though, as I've never done it
myself, you'll have to look around. Also, another important note: Once
you do an audio swap it's PERMANENT. You cannot restore your video to
it's original audio. So don't make the same mistake I did; at least TRY
to dispute before changing or muting your audio!
**EDIT ONE**
A few sources now have told me that if your dispute is
rejected, your account may face a penalty as sever as FULL video
deletion, or even account suspension. I wasn't aware of this until just
now so DO AT YOUR OWN RISK. But, what they mean by that is that if you
simply lie. DO NOT LIE. Do not say you have permission to use a song if
you really don't. Don't claim to own the song either. And don't
constantly send them complaints/emails. Constant bothering and
disputing when you've already once been rejected will also result in
penalty. It may not be the best way to go about it after all, but one
try without lying shouldn't hurt.
**EDIT ONE**
*OPTION 2 - SPECIAL YT LINK*
I'm
also looking into a certain link that seems to be somewhat of a
scapegoat for certain music/companies/artists. Maybe some of you have
noticed, but here's an example of what I mean: [link]
If
you notice there's a small link/picture on the right, this one in
particular says "Contains Content From: Rick Astley Official Channel".
To take an educated guess, I'm assuming this only applies for
music/songs/artists that have their own official YT accounts. I'm still
looking into exactly how to attain that link, because I'm almost
positive that having that link will immunize your video from copyright
infringement. I'll post the info when I find it.
*OPTION 3 - LEAVE OUT TITLE*
Some
of my friends have brought to my attention that in some cases if you
leave out a song title/artist, then it's a lot harder to track down and
flag the video. Like, leave the song titles/artist out of the main
title, description and video tags. This only works SOMETIMES though and
probably isn't 100% effective. For example, my FAQ2 video had no such
mention, but somehow was discovered and flagged anyway. So be careful
with it.
*OPTION 4 - DIFFERENT SONG VERSIONS*
This isn't
a tested theory yet, but as some of you may be aware, videos of covered
songs (amateur fans playing well-known songs) are not taken down from
YT. The same appears to go for karaoke versions of songs, as well as
remixes. So, if you get permission from the one(s) covering the song or
creator of the remix/karaoke and use those versions instead, chances
are you wont have your video taken down for copyright. Maybe even
covers by other mainstream bands are accepted, but I'm not positive. I
may do this with my removed videos later on.
*OPTION 5 - DON'T GO MAINSTREAM*
It
seems that the only removed videos/songs are mainstream American, even
much older American music. Music from things such as video games,
anime, TV shows and generally anything un-American (company) seem to
remain untouched, so if you can take a good song from one of those
categories and use it well in a video, go for it! As always though use
proper credit in case it IS removed, you still might be able to dispute
the claim.
Hopefully this information can help some people out
who either lost videos, or lose videos in the near future. If you
yourself have any information that I might've missed or can add on to,
just let me know. This copyright stuff is kinda bullshit. If YT were to
really be a 100% original content site, the only thing left would be
like.... V-Loggers. I mean if you wanna get technical, they'd have to
remove Smosh videos, like for example the video that made them big:
Singing the Pokemon theme song. I'm pretty sure Smosh doesn't own that
song, so that's an infringement right there. And hell, Smosh makes
MONEY from YT so that's even worse if you look at it that way! (I'm not
tryin' to bash Smosh, it's just a good example of why YT is getting
corrupttarded).
*OPTION 6 - UMG*
New suggestion!
Use music from the company UMG.
I dunno about other people but I had 3 videos with an attempted claim from UMG. But they were never removed or muted, and now all it says is 'claim retracted', meaning they just left my video alone and allowed it to stay. UMG seems really forgiving.
So if you wanna use a song, I suggest look it up on Wikipedia. A song/band page will usually also show what record company it's for, and chances are it's either WMG or UMG. WMG can suck my left nut, UMG has been very nice. And on a happy note, I looked up Ozone (The people who made Numa) and that's owned by UMG... so I'm happy.
**EDIT TWO**
I've heard from a source that YT is not fully
responsible for video deletions, but it's more along the lines of
Warner Music Company (and others). Apparently there is a huge 'war'
going on between Google and Warner, and the artists/bands themselves
are furious over the silencing of free publicity. I'm not sure what WE
can do about it, but it's not exactly Youtube's fault per say.
**EDIT TWO**
-Leggy
Categories: Youtube/Deviant Art




